Anambra community erupts in celebration as Appeal Court affirms monarch's dethronement
By Chuks Collins, Awka
Nov 17,2026
The Alor community, in Idemili South Council of Anambra State and countryhome of Senator Chris Ngige the immediate past Minister of Labour and Employment yesterday erupted in excitement and joyous celebration when news of receipt of the judgment order of Appeal Court's verdict which dethroned Chief McAnthony Elibe Okonkwo from their lawyers broke.
The Court of Appeal, Asaba Division had on October 30,2026 upheld/affirmed Okonkwo's dethronement and removal as the traditional ruler of Alor community by the Federal High Court verdict of
February 17, 2022.
The Court of Appeal had dismissed the appeal brought before it by the erstwhile monarch, and upheld the Anambra State High Court judgment invalidating his selection, installation and recognition of Mac-Anthony Elibe Okonkwo as the Igwe of Alor.
Consequently the Court of Appeal ruling confirms the removal of Igwe Mac-Anthony Okonkwo as traditional ruler of Alor, Idemili South Council of Anambra State.
Okonkwo's claim to the Igweship stool was challenged and he lost the appeal. The Court had averred that the process through which he was thrown up did not comply with the Alor People's Convention Constitution and the Traditional Rulers' Law of Anambra State; and that the government-appointed Caretaker Committee lacked the legal authority to conduct the selection process that threw Okonkwo up.
1* Germaine reasons thrown up included Who won and who lost?
Parties Outcome-
Mr. Frank Nwabufo Okoye, Mac-Anthony Elibe Okonkwo, and Anor. (Appellants) lost the appeal, while the
Incorporated Trustees of Alor Peoples Assembly (APA) and Chief Uzoma Igbonwa (Okife Alor) succeeded.
The Court of Appeal affirmed the High Court's judgment of 17th February 2022, with minor corrections and clarifications.
Again, Why did the Court reject the Igwe Elibe Okonkwo's claim?
The judgment identifies several important defects, including:
First: Failure to establish the required Ozo title.
The Court found that the 3rd Appellant (Okonkwo) had not proved he possessed the required Ozo title when he applied and was screened.
The judges rejected the argument that a candidate could qualify by promising to obtain the title before installation.
Second: Improper traditional installation.
The constitution had required specific traditional procedures, including the presentation of the staff of office by the appropriate Isigwu family representative (the Ezeofor Alor), and capping by the appropriate senior Ozo titleholder in Uruezeani Village.
The Court upheld findings that those requirements were not properly followed.
Third: The Caretaker Committee exceeded its authority.
Although appointed by the Anambra State Government to restore order in the community, the Caretaker Committee did not have the legal authority to conduct new Igwe selection.
The Court also relied on the earlier judicial invalidation of the statutory provision under which broader powers were claimed.
Fourth: Defects in government recognition.
The certificate of recognition was issued in 2014, whereas the government recognition was published in the Gazette in January 2021.
The Court held that this sequence was contrary to the statutory procedure and supported the nullification of the recognition.
These findings are principally discussed on pages 42–52 of the judgment.
*Does this mean the Igwe has been removed?
In legal effect, the judgment upholds the invalidation of his selection, installation and recognition.
It does not merely criticise the process. It affirms the High Court's substantive findings that the 3rd Appellant (Okonkwo) was not qualified or properly installed.
However, the judgment does not itself identify and install a replacement Igwe, because the replacement was not a subject of the appeal.
Who has the authority to organise a new selection?
This is one of the most important implications of the judgment.
The Court upheld the distinction between the Alor People's Convention and the Alor Peoples Assembly. It recognised the Convention as the town union.
The High Court's direction, affirmed on appeal, was for the President-General (Chief Uzoma Igbonwa) of the Convention, acting with the Regency Council, to commence the process of filling the vacant stool.
On pages 53–55, the appellate court specifically clarifies that the 2nd Respondent's status as President-General was supported by the documentary evidence before the Court.
Therefore, the judgment supports the Convention and Regency Council taking the prescribed steps toward a lawful succession process, rather than the Caretaker Committee conducting another selection.
Any fresh selection must comply with the governing constitutional and customary requirements as was done in the selection and installation of HRM, Igwe Collins Ebelechukwu Chukwumesili as Ezediohamma 3rd of Alor.
What did the Court finally order?
The formal orders on pages 54–55 are:
* The appeal is dismissed.
* The High Court judgment delivered on 17 February 2022 is affirmed, subject to correcting references in two orders from the 2011 Constitution to the 1992 Constitution.
*The direction to the 2nd Respondent as President-General (CHIEF UZOMA IGBONWA), in conjunction with the Regency Council, to commence the process of filling the vacant stool is affirmed.
*Each party bears its own legal costs.
All three appellate justices agreed that the appeal should be dismissed.
One of the key defence lawyers, Chief (Hon) Bona Oraekwe in his reaction expressed deep confidence that the Anambra State governor, Prof Chukwuma Soludo in view of the latest development has nothing more preventing him from presenting the Certificate of due Recognition to Okonkwo's replacement, HRH Igwe Collins Ebelechukwu Chukwumesili as the bonafide new Ezediohamma 111 of Alor without any further delay.
This, Oraekwe pointed out would douse the mounting communal tension in Alor and to also reassure other neighbouring communities with similar challenges that he's a lover and pursuer of peace for Anambra citizens.
While Okonkwo's legal team in their reaction to the appeal verdict disclosed that they would take time to study the judgement before deciding on the next line of action.

Comments
Post a Comment